Madras HC strikes down Tamil Nadu rule banning mineral transport to other states

The rule, introduced through an amendment, allowed the regulation of interstate transport of rough stones and related materials, including boulders, crushed stone, M-sand, metal jelly and ballast, to ensure adequate supply within Tamil Nadu.
Madras HC strikes down Tamil Nadu rule banning mineral transport to other states
Written by:
Published on: 

The Madras High Court on Tuesday, November 17, declared Rule 3A of the Tamil Nadu Prevention of Illegal Mining, Transportation and Storage of Minerals and Mineral Dealers Rules, 2011 as “unconstitutional,” which had empowered the Director of Geology and Mining to temporarily restrict the transport of certain minerals from Tamil Nadu to other states.

A Division Bench of Chief Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari and Justice G Arul Murugan also quashed the Director of Geology and Mining’s July 27 order imposing a three-month ban on transporting rough stones and their aggregates outside the state, except Puducherry and Karaikal. The ban was later extended for another three months from October 27.

The rule, introduced through an amendment on July 9, allowed the Director to regulate the interstate transport of rough stones and related materials, including boulders, crushed stone, M-sand, metal jelly and ballast, to ensure adequate supply within Tamil Nadu, The Hindu reported.

Quarry and crusher owners challenged the rule and the ban in a batch of petitions filed at the High Court’s principal seat in Chennai and its Madurai Bench. They argued that the state had exceeded its authority under Section 23C of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957, which allows states to frame rules to prevent illegal mining, transportation and storage of minerals. They also argued that the rule violated the Constitution’s protections for interstate trade.

The state government maintained that the rule was intended to balance local requirements, public safety and the state’s mineral needs against excessive transportation to other states. It also argued that the petitions had become infructuous because the ban period was due to end.

The court rejected the state’s position, holding that the rule exceeded the powers granted under the parent Act and infringed constitutional protections for trade between states. It said the state could not impose a ban on transporting minerals to other states through delegated legislation.

“Any measure of the State to ban transport of mineral to other States or restrict sales except as provided under Part XIII of the Constitution of India, is unconstitutional and would also traverse beyond the legislative competence,” the court said, according to Live Law. It added that delegated legislation “must restrict itself and strictly confine to the powers conferred upon it and cannot exceed them”.

“Under these circumstances, the impugned Rule 3-A of the Tamil Nadu Prevention of Illegal Mining, Transportation and Storage of Minerals and Mineral Dealers' Rules, 2011, is declared unconstitutional and ultra vires the parent Act.”

The Bench also referred to Supreme Court decisions on state control over minerals after excavation. It held that once the state had permitted mining and excavation, a temporary ban on transporting the minerals to other states had no reasonable connection to the stated objective of ensuring local availability.

The court said the state could regulate matters such as maximum vehicle loads, speed and other reasonable public safety requirements, but could not directly interfere with sales or prohibit transport beyond its borders. It also held that the rule could not have been introduced without the President’s prior sanction, as required for legislation restricting interstate trade.

Follow TNM's WhatsApp channel for news updates and story links.