

Madras High Court judge GR Swaminathan’s comments criticising Communist Party of India (Marxist) MP Su Venkatesan for his alleged double-standards, has triggered a political controversy, with the Left parties seeking action against the judge for making personal remarks.
On November 16, Justice GR Swaminathan said that while claiming to be a Communist, Venkatesan uses a high-end Mercedes Benz car and enjoys other luxuries. The Madras High Court judge claimed to witness his luxurious lifestyle during a chance encounter with the MP while boarding a train from Chennai.
“He claims to be a communist leader, you know? But he comes in a high-end Benz car, wears branded everything and I don't know whether the book royalties will sustain such a lifestyle,” he said while hearing a contempt petition concerning alleged irregularities in the procurement of books for public libraries in Tamil Nadu.
Justice Swaminathan allegedly made the remarks after CPI(M) MP Su Venkatesan criticised the judge’s suggestion that books on Kanchi Shankaracharya be placed in the library section where books supplied by Agal Vilakku Publications had been stocked, as a way to atone for the alleged fraud.
MP Su Venkatesan found fault with his remarks and said that the issue constituted corruption and that those responsible ought to be punished in accordance with the law. He argued that punishing corruption was the responsibility of judges, whereas prescribing atonement for sins was the work of astrologers.
A day after Swaminathan’s attack, the MP took to X (Twitter) to deny that he owns a luxurious car. He said that criticism with unverified facts “reveals prejudice but also degenerates into a personal attack.”
He termed the criticism as a “cheap personal attack.” “That car does not belong to me. To this day, I do not own a car.”
“My train journey is undertaken under the travel entitlement accorded to a Member of Parliament. Travelling first class does not make someone's views wrong, just as travelling in the sleeper class does not automatically make what someone says right.”
“An intellectually aware society will not fail to see through such comparisons. The respect a person commands in society is shaped by their ideas and their actions. We continue to be questioned about the shirts we wear, the cars in which we arrive and the class in which we travel,” he said.
Meanwhile, CPI (M) state secretary P Shanmugam and CPI state secretary M Veerapandian issued separate statements criticising GR Swaminathan’s remarks for allegedly violating judicial norms by attacking political leaders. The Left leaders urged the Madras High Court Chief Justice to take appropriate action against him.
Shanmugam said this was not the first time Justice Swaminathan had made controversial remarks in public and alleged that several of his speeches reflected caste-based views. Referring to the judge's suggestion that all volumes of the book of Kanchi seer Chandrashekharendra Saraswati VIII (Maha Periyava) should be placed in the libraries to atone for the alleged wrongdoing. He said the remarks reflected varnasrama ideology and hostility.
He also recalled that MPs had already submitted a notice seeking the judge's removal, citing his alleged partisan ideological positions. The CPI(M) state committee urged the Chief Justice to take appropriate action to protect public confidence in the judiciary and uphold its dignity.
Veerapandian accused Swaminathan of repeatedly violating judicial norms and conventions by criticising political leaders at public functions and making remarks resembling those of a political party leader. He also accused the judge of making comments with a religious bias despite the constitutional requirement for judges to uphold secularism.
He said that the judge's remarks on the Periyar Arivulagam library procurement controversy was rooted in superstition and also reflected his varnasrama leanings.
Follow TNM's WhatsApp channel for news updates and story links.