‘Independent judiciary needs free media’: Justice S Muralidhar at Media Foundation Awards

The Caravan’s Jatinder Kaur Tur won the Chameli Devi Jain Award at the Media Foundation Awards. Priyanka Tupe and Rokibuz Zaman won inaugural awards for Gender and Fearless Journalism.
Three people stand on a stage holding awards at The Media Foundation Journalism Awards event. The backdrop displays "The Media Foundation Journalism Awards BG Verghese Memorial Lecture" along with the organization's logo and a portrait of an elderly man wearing glasses. The individuals are dressed in formal attire, smiling while posing for the photograph. A pink gift bag is visible on the side.
Journalists Priyanka Tupe, Jatinder Kaur Tur and Rokibuz Zaman with their awards
Written by:
Published on

By Ankita Dhar Karmakar


Jatinder Kaur Tur of The Caravan won this year’s Chameli Devi Jain Award for Outstanding Woman Media Person of the Year at the Media Foundation Awards. The event, held at the India International Centre, New Delhi, on Friday, March 21, also saw the introduction of two new journalism awards – the Kamla Mankekar Award for Journalism on Gender and the Vishwa Nath-Delhi Press Award for Fearless Journalism.

Priyanka Tupe from BehanBox won the inaugural Kamla Mankekar Award while Rokibuz Zaman of Scroll received the Vishwa Nath Delhi Press Award. Divya Arya from BBC Hindi received an honorable mention for two of her video series 'Hum, Bharat ke Musalmaan' and 'Hindu Dharm: Mera Marm'.

The event also featured the 11th BG Verghese Memorial Lecture, delivered by Justice S Muralidhar. In his hour-long address, he spoke about the deteriorating press freedom in India, noting that “internet shutdowns have become routine.” He presented statistics illustrating India's decline in the World Press Freedom Index, where the country currently ranks 159.

“A truly free media needs an independent judiciary, and an independent judiciary needs a free media,” he remarked, highlighting the judiciary’s weakening role in safeguarding free speech. He also pointed out how criticism of the government is increasingly being labeled as “anti-national”, citing instances such as the crackdown following the BBC documentary, India: The Modi Question, and subsequent raids, the use of Pegasus spyware on journalists, and the recent ban on Vikatan, a Tamil magazine, over a cartoon depicting Modi and Trump.

Taking a dig at the mainstream media, he described it as not just “noisy” but a “chaotic cacophony.” He added, “Worse, there is a virtual news war out there on the Internet. Fact-checkers have a tough time keeping track of fake news and dealing with troll armies that deploy social media handles and bots – some of them created by the IT cells of political parties.”

“The big challenge is to keep the news free,” he further stressed and underlined that there was a need to keep news away from corporate sponsorships.

The Chameli Devi Jain Award, instituted in 1980, honours women journalists who demonstrate excellence and courage in reporting. Named after freedom fighter and social reformer Chameli Devi Jain, it has been awarded since 1982 to some of India’s most respected journalists, including Greeshma Kuthar, Ritika Chopra, Neerja Chowdhury, Sevanti Ninan, Patricia Mukhim, Pamela Philipose, Sunita Narain, and Nirupama Subramanian.

The Kamla Mankekar Award is named after Kamla Mankekar, a pioneering post-Independence journalist committed to gender justice. The Vishwa Nath-Delhi Press Award is dedicated to Vishwa Nath, founder of Delhi Press (which publishes The Caravan, Sarita, Champak, Grihshobha, among others), known for his fearless journalism and defiance of institutional power.

Awardees were selected based on five submitted stories, evaluated by a jury comprising journalists Rajesh John, Seema Mustafa (Editor-in-Chief, The Citizen) and Supriya Sharma (Executive Editor, Scroll). The foundation received 57 entries for the Chameli Devi Award, 54 for the Kamla Manekar Award and 44 for the Vishwa Nath-Delhi Press Award.

Stories that won them the award

Jatinder Kaur Tur – Chameli Devi Jain Award for Outstanding Woman Media Person of the Year

The religious paranoia behind Punjab's sacrilege killings

The men behind Amritpal Singh’s election campaign from jail

Army officers testify that two generals oversaw the torture and murder of civilians in Poonch

Why farmers in Haryana and Punjab disallowed the BJP and others from campaigning

Anger among Jammu’s business community imperils the BJP’s election prospects


Priyanka Tupe – Kamla Mankekar Award

Rural Job Scheme Has Yet To Benefit The Most Marginalised Women of Maharashtra

Rape Survivors From Nomadic Tribes Get No State Support, Compensation or Counselling

Despite Law, Caste Panchayats Still Run Kangaroo Courts In Maharashtra

Why A Dalit Woman Is Demanding A Cremation Grounds For Dalits In Her Village

Cost of Maternal Health Is Pushing Families Into A Debt Trap In Maharashtra 

Rokibuz Zaman – Vishwa Nath Delhi Press Award

Why Assam’s Muslims see discrimination in state’s flagship scheme for the rural landless

‘No Muslim can win, now or in the future’: In Assam’s Barpeta, delimitation fears confirmed

In Assam, over a thousand Muslim families evicted from railway land – but not their Hindu neighbours

Why residents of Assam capital are not buying the chief minister’s claim of ‘flood jihad’

Why Assam’s Detention Centre Is Filling Up Again 

This report was republished from Newslaundry as part of The News Minute-Newslaundry alliance. Read more about our partnership here.

Subscriber Picks

No stories found.
The News Minute
www.thenewsminute.com