In March 2013, Vaiyapuri, a resident of Thirukkurungudi in Tirunelveli district, was riding his bike on a bridge when three police officers stopped his vehicle. The young man was asked to produce documents for his bike and when he presented photocopies, the police officers allegedly threw them to the floor and demanded to know how much money he had.
In his petition to the Madras High Court, Vaiyapuri had stated that when he told the police personnel that he had only Rs 150, he was abused and asked why he needed a bike when he barely had cash. They then allegedly took him to the station, stripped him naked and thrashed him. He sustained serious injuries on his thigh in the assault. Later, his thumb impression was taken on a blank paper.
The assault which left Vaiyapuri needing medical treatment and unable to walk was led by none other than Sub Inspector Balakrishnan who along with P Raghuganesh, another Sub Inspector, have been suspended in connection with the deaths of Jayaraj and Bennix in Sathankulam in Thoothukudi district.
News article in a Tamil daily from 2013 detailing harassment endured by Vaiyapuri
TNM spoke to activists and other victims of the duo, only to find a trail of brutal attacks by the sub inspectors, who have repeatedly gotten away with their violent behaviour.
âIn Vaiyapuriâs case, Balakrishnan came and apologised and said that his whole life would be ruined if he was convicted for the brutality,â says Pon Karthikeyan, who was Vaiyapuriâs advocate. The victim had approached the court for a compensation of Rs 1 lakh and asked that the offending police officials be punished.
âMy client and Balakrishnan then agreed for an out of court settlement. But it seems that the sub inspector never actually changed at all. As a lawyer, I feel terrible that we couldnât stop him seven years ago,â adds the advocate.
Balakrishnan was reportedly transferred multiple times following this incident over various allegations of abuse until he came to the Sathankulam station in 2019, where he and Sub Inspector Raghuganesh allegedly terrorised residents together.
34-year-old Lazares, a pastor from Palaniappuram near Sathankulam, was a victim of their horrific violence on February 21 this year along with 10 others. The pastor and his colleagues had been distributing pamphlets in a village when police picked them based on complaints from local people.
âNine of us went to the station and Sub Inspector Raghuganesh didnât even ask us a single question, instead he started by slapping me across the face,â says Lazares. âHe then proceeded to hit our backs, buttocks, feet and thighs with a lathi for over an hour. We were pushed into the lockup at around 12 noon and stayed there till 6 pm. When our panchayat chief from Karungkadal came to enquire, he was also beaten up,â adds Lazares.
Even a man with disabilities, Ayyadurai, who was with the pastor, was mercilessly beaten, says Lazares.
âFinally villagers and Chrisitian groups had to intervene before they let us out,â he adds. âWhile Raghuganesh led the assault, Balakrishanan abused us verbally,â he alleges.
The National Christian Council then provided legal support to the pastor and information was sent to the State Human Right Commission and the Minorities Commission. They also informed the Deputy Inspector General of Police.
âThe Minorities commission sent a notice to the Collector and the DIG. The DSP then called us for an inquiry,â says National Christian Council state coordinator CS Jebasing. âBut instead of taking action, the police officials told us that the SI will apologise and that we should withdraw the complaint,â he adds.
The victims, however, refused and demanded that the policemen who attacked them be transferred.
Pastor Lazares who was allegedly assaulted by sub inspector Raghu Ganesh
âThings didnât move after this inquiry because of the pandemic,â says Jebasing. âBut if they had listened to us then, two lives could have been saved now,â he adds.
Even these complaints, however, did nothing to hamper the violent actions of the two policemen.
Human Right activist Henri Tiphagne tells TNM that on May 25, a 29-year-old construction worker named Mahendran had been picked up by the Sathankulam police. He was the younger brother of Durairaj, who was absconding after being accused in the murder of a man named Jayakumar.
Jayakumar, according to many sources, was touted to be a police informer, and his death had enraged the police, who in turn tortured those connected with the murder.
The young man was allegedly brutally assaulted in the station before being let off but died in mid June from the injuries he sustained. His family and activists allege that the assault at the police station led to the deterioration of his health.
âThe family was too afraid to open up about this earlier. But now seeing how activists are bringing it up and how other villagers are supporting them, they have spoken to the magistrate about the assault on Mahendran,â says Henri.
And while Mahendran succumbed to his injuries, Raja Singh, another accused in the Jayakumar murder case, has also showed signs of severe assault.
The Madurai bench in an order dated June 26 noted that it had received a report from the Principal district judge of Thoothukudi informing them that Raja Singh who was imprisoned at the Kovilpatti sub-jail had suffered serious injuries.
âRaja Singh is crucial to our case because he was in the same jail as Jayaraj and Bennix,â says advocate Vishnuvardhan, who is representing Jayarajâs wife Selva Raniâs plea regarding the post mortem of the two deceased. âTomorrow if something happens to Raja Singh, who is also from Sathankulam, this will become an even more serious issue. So the court has directed the Chief Judicial Magistrate of the district to conduct an enquiry into the matter and submit a report,â he adds.
According to Lazares, everyone in the villages adjoining the police station were aware of the âsadisticâ attitude of the policemen in Sathankulam.
When TNM contacted Thoothukudi Superintendent of Police Arun Balagopalan, he confirmed that the previous complaints against the two sub inspectors were recorded and that enquiries are underway in the matter.
Trigger warning - Image of Pastor Lazares' injuries allegedly due to police brutality