Why has the Supreme Court let two Bilkis Bano convicts out of jail? | Let Me Explain 180 | Pooja Prasanna
"Today I find myself losing the very justice I had fought so hard to win. Familiar fears are resurfacing. I am scared once again."
These are the words of Bilkis Bano, 24 years after she survived one of the most horrific crimes during the 2002 Gujarat riots.
She won her case in a trial court. She won in the High Court. She even won in the Supreme Court.
Yet, this November, two men convicted of gang-raping her and murdering members of her family have walked out of prison again. Their sentences had been suspended and they’ve also given bail.
And the Supreme Court didn't even consider it necessary to inform Bilkis Bano before hearing their pleas.
We looked into the court records and found that the state of Maharashtra and the state of Gujarat probably did not even file a counter affidavit in the appeal.
Let Me Explain
Justice delayed is one thing. Justice repeatedly taken away is another. And when even the justice system in the country needs to be questioned, independent journalism cannot look away.
At The News Minute, we stay with stories because we are convinced we must. We question, investigate and hold those in power accountable. We depend on readers like you to keep this journalism independent. If you believe it matters, please subscribe to TNM. We are offering a 20% discount only this week.
Like LME? Support the show: https://rzp.io/rzp/support-lme
Like our journalism? Become a subscriber: https://www.thenewsminute.com/subscription
Subscribe to The News Minute for six months & get 20% off:
For viewers in India: https://bit.ly/4AHwync
For viewers outside India: https://bit.ly/4jppJRf
On November 17, Bilkis Bano released a statement that should unsettle every single one of us.
She said,“I have learned to smile. Yet today I find myself losing the very justice. I am scared once again.”
She won her trial in 2008, and won her appeal in the Bombay High Court 2017.
She won in the Supreme Court in 2024 and the judges sent eleven men convicted of gang-raping her and murdering her family back to jail.
Yet here we are in November 2026, and two of those men are walking out again—with the Supreme Court’s permission, and without Bilkis even being informed.
Many think justice is like a finish line. You go to court, you fight, you get a conviction, and you rebuild your life.
For Bilkis Bano, India’s legal system has turned justice into a life sentence of its own.
In March 2002, during the Gujarat riots, Bilkis was nineteen and five months pregnant when a mob attacked her family in Dahod district.
She was gang-raped. Fourteen members of her family were killed or went missing, including her three-year-old daughter Saleha, whose head was smashed against a stone right in front of Bilkis.
The case was transferred to Maharashtra by the Supreme Court and in 2008, a special CBI court in Mumbai sentenced 11 men to life imprisonment. This order was later confirmed by the Mumbai High Court in 2017.
Two of the rape and murder convicts- Bipinchand Kaniyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya went to the Supreme Court on August 15, 2025 with a Special Leave Petition.
Strangely, the CBI that investigated the case and Bilkis Bano were not named as respondents in the case.
Only the states of Maharashtra and Gujarat were
The case came up around 6 times in 7 months.
Let me take you through the Supreme court’s office record on October 28, when the case came up last and this is what it says.
Both the states- had not filed counter affidavits. Why?
They did oppose the appeal orally, but in such an important case, were these affidavits filed?
The Gujarat and Maharashtra governments must answer.
And the woman who survived that attack—the woman who has had to shift homes repeatedly for over two decades to protect her children—was never informed about the appeal.
How did she find out? Not from a court notice. Not from a prosecutor. She found out through news reports.
In her statement on Tuesday, she asked two questions that expose the rot at the heart of how we treat victims:"How could they not even inform me? How could they not even make sure my voice was heard in their courtroom?"
Over the last decade, Indian criminal jurisprudence has evolved to recognize victim participation.
When a convict applies for bail, the court is obligated to issue a notice to the victim. Such a provision may not exist when it comes to suspension of sentence, but- and this is important- In heinous crimes like gang-rape and murder, the Supreme Court itself has repeatedly held that a survivor is not a passive bystander once the trial ends.
In a suspension of sentence in a grave offence, does the victim not have a right to be notified and heard?
Now to the next question- Didn't the Supreme Court already block their release in 2024? How did this happen?
It happened because the defence found a completely different legal door.
What the Gujarat government granted in 2022 was remission. Remission is an executive decision by a state government to permanently forgive or cut short the rest of a prisoner's sentence. That is what the Supreme Court quashed in 2024.
What just happened in 2026 is a suspension of sentence pending appeal.
This is a judicial order under Section 389 of the CrPC—now Section 430 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita.
Remember 2017, when the Bombay High Court confirmed their life sentences?
Right after that, the convicts filed appeals in the Supreme Court challenging their convictions.
Because of massive backlogs in our courts,those appeals have been sitting unheard for nine years. So while that final challenge was still pending, two of the men filed a special leave petition.
So, lawyers for Joshi and Modhiya didn't ask for permanent remission. They went to the Supreme Court and argued: We have spent over seventeen years in prison, one of us has a severe physical disability, and you still haven't heard our final appeal. Suspend our sentences and give us bail until you decide the main case.
And the court said yes.
Think about what Bilkis Bano has already survived.
After the ghastly crime in 2002, the local Gujarat police closed the case, claiming they couldn't trace the accused. Bilkis refused to back down. She approached the National Human Rights Commission and the Supreme Court.
The CBI took over, and the Supreme Court moved the entire trial out of Gujarat to Maharashtra because a fair hearing wasn't possible in her home state.
In 2008, a Mumbai special court convicted eleven men and sentenced them to life imprisonment. In 2017, the Bombay High Court upheld those convictions.
That should have been the end of it. She had won in the trial court. She had won in the High Court.
Instead, in August 2022, the Gujarat government quietly granted all eleven convicts early release, and they walked out of prison.
Radheshyam Shah, Jaswant Chaturbhai Nai, Keshubhai Vadaniya, Baka Vadaniya, Rajibhai Soni, Rameshbhai Chauhan, Shailesh Bhatt, Bipin Chand Joshi, Govindbhai Nai, Mitesh Bhatt and Pradip Modhiya walked out of the Godhra prison. They were welcomed with sweets and then garlanded at the Vishwa Hindu Parishad’s office
Bilkis had to go back to the Supreme Court all over again.
And in January 2024, a bench of Justices B.V. Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan delivered a historic verdict. They struck down Gujarat’s order, ruled that the state had usurped Maharashtra’s jurisdiction, and sent all eleven men back to jail.
While reading out that judgment in 2024, Justice Nagarathna spoke powerfully about the rule of law, a woman’s dignity, and the psychological toll inflicted on a survivor. The highest court in the land was protecting her.
Which brings us to this week—and why the contrast is so jarring.
Stop and look at what that means. In India, life imprisonment means prison for the remainder of your natural life. Not fourteen years. Not seventeen years. Yet, because the Supreme Court itself hasn't found the time in nine years to hear their appeal, the two men walked out.
The court’s own delay has now become the excuse to let two of the men out.
Even the math raises eyebrows. The order cites over seventeen years of incarceration, yet it doesn't clarify whether that calculation properly deducted the seventeen months these men spent roaming free between August 2022 and January 2024 before their remission was cancelled.
And the worst part? This isn't just about two men. There are nine other convicts still sitting in that jail.
In criminal law, one of the strongest weapons a defence lawyer has is parity. If two convicts get relief because they have served seventeen years and their appeal is pending, the remaining nine convicts now have a ready-made template to file identical pleas. Unless this order is challenged and stayed, we may watch the remaining nine walk out one by one.
Bilkis Bano has already announced she will challenge this suspension of sentence.
As Bilkis wrote this week, no woman, no survivor, and no citizen should have to endure an eternal fight for justice for the rest of her life.
Like LME? Support the show: https://rzp.io/rzp/support-lme
Like our journalism? Become a subscriber: https://www.thenewsminute.com/subscription
Subscribe to The News Minute for six months & get 20% off:
For viewers in India: https://bit.ly/4AHwync
For viewers outside India: https://bit.ly/4jppJRf
Produced by Akshay Lal, script by Pooja Prasanna, camera by Ajay R, edit by Nikhil Sekhar ET
Follow TNM's WhatsApp channel for news updates and story links.
