India’s falling poverty numbers v/s reality | LME 179 | Pooja Prasanna
India has nearly 1.4 billion people. And according to the World Bank's latest estimates, just 2.6% of them live in extreme poverty.
Nearly 500 million peopple are estimated to have escaped extreme poverty in just around 15 years..
The government can certainly claim this as an achievement. And for a government that has made development its biggest political pitch, these numbers make for a compelling story.
But does this mean that 97.4% of Indians are doing well economically? Not quite.
As I keep saying, the story most times lies beyond the headline, which is why there is another picture of India's economy that deserves attention.
Using the government's own consumption survey data, the Thali Index shows that nearly 30% of Indians still struggle to afford two basic, balanced meals a day.
RBI reports show household debt is climbing while net financial savings have dropped.
And official PLFS data show that, once adjusted for inflation, real wages have barely moved.
So how do we reconcile these seemingly contradictory pictures? What exactly does the World Bank's poverty estimate tell us, and what does it leave out?
We often come across so many numbers about how much the country is progressing. But how often do we stop to ask what these numbers actually mean? How are they calculated? And what might they be leaving out?
At Let Me Explain, we've always tried to break down the data and put them in context. It is important to celebrate India’s achievements but if they are not based on hard realities, then it will help only the government, not the people of the country. We'll keep doing this work. And you can help us keep going. Subscribe to The News Minute, this is the last week we are giving a 20% discount on subscriptions.
Like LME? Support the show: https://rzp.io/rzp/support-lme
Like our journalism? Become a subscriber: https://pages.razorpay.com/sub20off
For viewers outside India: https://buy.stripe.com/8x26oH0hCfqC3K44k34ow0s
According to the latest World Bank brief, extreme poverty in India has fallen from 27.1% in 2011 to 2.6% today.
But there are four things we need to look at before accepting this number at face value:
How free government benefits are counted.
How India's poverty surveys have changed.
What's happening to jobs and wages.
And whether the poverty line itself is an adequate measure of economic security.
Let's start with how India counts its poor.
India doesn't measure poverty by asking people how much they earn. Nearly 90% of the workforce is informal, like street vendors, farm workers, construction labourers, with no regular payslips or income records.
So instead, government surveys looked at how much households spend.
But in the newer consumption surveys of 2022–23 and 2023–24, there's an important change.
Surveyors no longer just record what families buy with their own money. They also calculate the value of goods people receive through welfare schemes. Either for free or at subsidised rates. This includes foodgrains through ration shops and other government-provided goods like cooking gas, laptops, cycles, books, uniforms etc. Their estimated market value is added to a household's consumption expenditure.
And just like that, the spreadsheet can say a family is no longer poor.
Of course, free rations make a real difference. They help families survive. But there's a difference between being able to afford your necessities and depending on government support to meet them.
If your escape from poverty depends on subsidies, how financially secure are you?
And what happens if those benefits are reduced, or prices rise?
There is another problem when we compare poverty figures from 2011 with those from 2023–24. The surveys themselves have changed.
In 2011–12, surveyors visited a household once and asked people to recall their expenditure over the previous 30 days.
In the newer surveys, households were visited three times, with more detailed questions.
Think about your own spending. Can you remember every cup of tea, auto ride or packet of biscuits you bought last month?
You probably can't. But if someone asks you several times, with a detailed list of expenses, you're likely to remember more.
That means reported household spending can go up simply because of the way questions are asked, not because people are actually spending more.
The selection of households and the sampling methods also changed, making direct comparisons with older surveys more complicated.
And this isn't just a theoretical concern.
When survey methods change this substantially, statisticians normally conduct what's called a bridge survey. They test both methods side by side to understand how much of the difference comes from actual economic improvement and how much comes from the change in methodology.
India did not conduct such a survey.
Research from the Center for Global Development has pointed out that if India's actual extreme poverty rate is closer to 6% rather than 2.6%, that would mean a difference of around 50 million people. This is a hypothetical difference based on the 6% estimate,
There's another striking detail. The World Bank's 2025 estimates put India's extreme poverty rate at 5.3% for 2022–23. The latest brief brings that figure down to 2.6%.
So these numbers need to be understood in the context of changing data and methodology.
When poverty genuinely falls on a large scale, you would expect to see it reflected in the job market.
In the last few years, due to internal and external factors, economic growth has slowed, private investment has stagnated, and factories aren’t creating enough jobs for the millions of young people entering the workforce.
Today, more than 45% of India's workforce is still employed in agriculture, even though the sector contributes a much smaller share of the economy.
The World Bank's extreme poverty threshold is currently $3 a day, adjusted for purchasing power across countries.
But remember, this is a measure of extreme poverty. It is not a measure of whether someone can afford a reasonably secure life.
India's own official poverty line hasn't been updated since 2011, when it was pegged at roughly Rs 32 a day.
So we are dealing with a poverty benchmark that doesn't adequately reflect today's cost of living.
Let's move away from these benchmarks and look at something more tangible: food on a plate.
Economists recently used the same 2023–24 government consumption data to calculate something called the Thali Index.
The question was simple: Can Indian households afford two basic, balanced meals a day, consisting of staples such as dal, rice, roti and vegetables?
Even after accounting for free foodgrains distributed by the government, the findings are stark.
Around 40% of rural Indians and 10% of urban Indians cannot afford two basic meals a day.
That's nearly 30% of the population.
So we have one set of statistics telling us that 97.4% of Indians have escaped extreme poverty, while another suggests that nearly a third cannot afford two balanced meals a day.
Now, none of this means India hasn't made progress. Welfare delivery has improved. Basic infrastructure has reached millions of villages. These are real achievements.
But a poverty line is essentially a pass-or-fail test.
If a school lowers its pass mark to 3 out of 100, suddenly almost everyone may pass. But that doesn't mean the students have learnt more. The benchmark has simply changed.
Poverty reduction cannot be measured by one headline number alone.
Poverty statistics shape public policy. If the message is that extreme poverty has fallen to just 2.6%, there is a danger that the urgency to address hunger, stagnant wages, unemployment and inequality will disappear.
The real question isn't just how many people have crossed an extreme poverty line.
It's whether they have the means to live with dignity and financial security.
Like LME? Support the show: https://rzp.io/rzp/support-lme
Like our journalism? Become a subscriber now and get 20% off: https://pages.razorpay.com/sub20off
For viewers outside India: https://buy.stripe.com/8x26oH0hCfqC3K44k34ow0s
Produced by Megha Mukundan, script by Pooja Prasanna, camera by Ajay R, edited by Jaseem Ali
Follow TNM's WhatsApp channel for news updates and story links.
