

Justice Karnan, who challenged the Brahminical judiciary and society through forms of dissent and methods of resistance that they considered eccentric and unacceptable, passed away on November 13.
Neither the sold-out mainstream media nor the alternate media appeared to have remembered him much, let alone the questions he raised in ways that seemed bizarre to a civil society conditioned by Brahminical notions of civility.
Today, the institutionalised Brahminism, intolerance towards Dalits, and deep-rooted corruption operating at the highest levels of the supposedly 'neutral judiciary' have been exposed to an extent that no one can deny.
Yet, when Justice Karnan spoke about these realities in blunt and unconventional terms, the judiciary subjected him to punishment in a manner almost unprecedented in its history.
In fact, the Sharmas caught with corrupt money, the Mishras who climbed the judicial ladder by currying favour with ruling governments, the supposedly brilliant Guptas harbouring deep prejudices against reservation and minority rights, and the Vyasas and Dikshits who swear allegiance to the Constitution only to uphold Sanatana dharma—all of them have literally vindicated every allegation Justice Karnan made against the judiciary.
It is therefore necessary to bring Karnan's story, the challenge he posed, and the questions he raised before civil society once again.
Why was Karnan unacceptable?
The challenges and resistance posed by Justice Karnan, a Dalit judge who served in the Madras and Calcutta High Courts, were neither straightforward nor simple. They were somewhat complex. Nevertheless, rather than understanding the substance of his resistance, the Supreme Court, the media, and 'civil' society often dismissed it as the anarchic conduct of a deranged judge.
Not stopping there, the Supreme Court, for the first time in the country's history, sentenced a sitting High Court judge to six months' imprisonment on charges of contempt of court.
If Indian society is to acquire genuine civic consciousness, it must, at least now, understand these questions in all their complexity and entirety. For that, we must first understand the complexities of the case against Justice Karnan.
The simple yet complicated story of Justice Karnan
Born into a Dalit family in a small village in Tamil Nadu in 1955, Karnan obtained his law degree in 1983 and practised law in the Madras High Court for 25 years.
In 2009, the then Chief Justice of the Madras High Court, recommended his appointment as a High Court judge to the Supreme Court Collegium. The Collegium, headed by the then Chief Justice of India KG Balakrishnan, accepted the recommendation, and Karnan was appointed a High Court judge in 2009. He served there until 2016.
In 2011, Justice Karnan held a press conference, alleging acts of discrimination by his fellow High Court judges. He repeatedly complained that the Chief Justice of the Madras High Court was not assigning him important cases because of his caste background. On several occasions, he also spoke openly and bluntly about casteism and nepotism prevailing in the High Courts and the Supreme Court.
In 2015, he publicly objected to being excluded from proceedings concerning the selection and appointment of judges to the subordinate judiciary. He complained to the Chief Justice of the High Court that caste prejudice against him was responsible for all this.
However, instead of investigating his allegations, the then Chief Justice of the Madras High Court, Sanjay Kaul, requested the Chief Justice of India to transfer Karnan to another High Court.
Accordingly, Karnan was transferred to the Calcutta High Court in 2016. However, Karnan exercised his authority to issue an order staying his own transfer.
Subsequently, TS Thakur, who was the Chief Justice of India, summoned Karnan to his chambers and persuaded him to accept the transfer. Karnan then moved to the Calcutta High Court.
In 2017, after joining the Calcutta High Court, Justice Karnan wrote a lengthy and confidential letter to the Prime Minister, detailing how 32 judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts were allegedly involved in corruption and demanding action against them.
Prime Minister Modi forwarded the letter to then Chief Justice of India JS Khehar.
Without conducting any independent investigation into his allegations, Justice Khehar initiated a suo motu contempt of court case against Justice Karnan, a sitting High Court judge, for the first time in the country's history. A bench comprising the seven senior-most judges of the Supreme Court was constituted to hear the case.
Responding to this move, Justice Karnan alleged that he was being humiliated because he was a Dalit and filed a complaint against the seven judges under the SC/ST Atrocities Act.
In retaliation, the Supreme Court directed the Calcutta High Court not to assign any cases to Karnan's bench. It also ordered a compulsory medical examination to determine whether Karnan was mentally fit.
In response, Justice Karnan ordered the Delhi Police to arrest all seven Supreme Court judges under the Atrocities Act and produce them before his residential office.
The Supreme Court annulled all of Karnan's orders. It also directed the media not to publish his orders and, on May 9, 2017, sentenced him to six months' imprisonment for contempt of court.
The caste blindness of civil society
Throughout this entire episode, what stood out to the media and civil society—or rather, what they chose to see—was only Justice Karnan's anarchic and intemperate responses.
Even if both these elements were reflected in Karnan's reactions, was it not the Savarna-dominated judiciary that institutionally pushed him into such a state of mind?
How and why did Parliament, the government, society, and the media remain blind to the anarchic and unconstitutional actions of the Madras High Court and the Supreme Court as institutions in their treatment of Karnan?
First, how did the Supreme Court conclude that Karnan's allegations of judicial corruption were entirely fabricated and therefore constituted contempt of court, without conducting even a single independent internal investigation into those allegations?
After all, in 2009, the well-known lawyer Prashant Bhushan had also alleged that more than half of the previous 16 Chief Justices of India were corrupt.
In 2012, senior BJP leader Arun Jaitley, who later became a Cabinet Minister in the Modi government, openly criticised the higher judiciary, saying "pre-retirement judgements are influenced by a desire for a post-retirement job."
That was not all.
A note by former chief minister of Arunachal Pradesh, Kalikho Pul, written on August 8, 2016, a day before be died by suicide had made serious allegations against two senior judges of the Supreme Court, including Justice Khehar, who later became the Chief Justice of India.
In 2021, researchers from the prestigious National University of Singapore published a scholarly research paper titled Jobs for Justice(s): Corruption in the Supreme Court of India, examining institutionalised corruption in India's Supreme Court.
The study found that several judges who delivered judgments favouring the government subsequently received one form of favour or another from the government.
More recently, did not the bundles of currency notes discovered at Justice Yashwant Varma’s residence provide further evidence supporting Karnan's allegations?
Therefore, Karnan's allegations were not baseless. Nor did he raise them through unconstitutional means.
He wrote to the Prime Minister, the leader of the ruling party in Parliament, which has the authority to initiate action against judges.
But instead of taking action, the Prime Minister forwarded the allegations to the very person against whom they had been made.
Why did civil society remain blind to this?
Second, it was undoubtedly an extreme step for a High Court judge to order the arrest of Supreme Court judges, particularly before any offences had been proved. Karnan was wrong in doing so.
But the Supreme Court committed an even greater wrong.
Although the Supreme Court is the final authority in judicial matters, constitutionally the High Courts are not subordinate to the Supreme Court.
Moreover, under the Constitution, only Parliament has the authority to remove a High Court or Supreme Court judge from office. Even the Supreme Court does not possess that power.
If that is so, under what law did the Supreme Court issue an order effectively stripping Karnan of his judicial powers by directing that no cases be assigned to him?
Under which Article of the Constitution did it not only initiate contempt proceedings against a High Court judge but also constitute a seven-judge bench to try him?
All these actions were not merely unconstitutional. They were also measures with extremely serious and long-lasting consequences.
This was institutional anarchy on the part of the Supreme Court, far more condemnable than the individual anarchy of Justice Karnan.
How did civil society remain blind to this?
Can there be two different standards for the same kind of wrongdoing? Why?
Even when the wrongdoing was of the same nature, was not the difference in punishment rooted in institutional intolerance and contempt towards Karnan's social background?
Third, in 2011, Karnan broke judicial conventions by holding a press conference against his colleagues.
It was described as an extreme act. It was called insanity.
On January 12, 2018, four senior Supreme Court judges held a press conference, delivering a scathing criticism of the apex court and raising concerns over allocation of cases by the Chief Justice of India.
Civil society, however, hailed that press conference as an absolutely necessary judicial rebellion.
Both press conferences concerned corruption within the judiciary.
Yet why did civil society readily accept one as legitimate while dismissing the other as an extreme, uncivilised act of a deranged mind?
In fact, Karnan maintained consistency and steadiness in his opposition to judicial corruption.
Fourth, Karnan publicly objected, in violation of judicial conventions, when a case that should have come before his bench was transferred to another bench. This, too, was an extreme step.
There were allegations that Chief Justice Dipak Misra was misusing his powers as the "Master of the Roster" to transfer cases which may have an impact on the Modi government to the relatively junior bench of Arun Mishra.
Was it not precisely in protest against this that the four senior-most Supreme Court judges held their historic public press conference?
More recently, hasn't Justice Sanjay Kaul himself written about how Chief Justice Chandrachud was deferential towards the government and used to seek pre-approval before the Collegium discussed names for judicial appointments. In an interview to Karan Thapar, Kaul also spoke about how Chandrachud attempted to take away the PMLA case from a bench he presided over.
And after becoming Chief Justice of India, Justice Ranjan Gogoi went so far as to preside over the hearing concerning allegations made against him by a female colleague.
Why did our civil society not regard all these incidents as examples of insanity, abuse of power, and repeated acts of contempt of court?
Democratic morality and Brahminism
Yes, Karnan's resistance was neither straightforward nor simple.
Karnan himself was a judge vested with authority, challenging both the institutional arrogance of a Supreme Court that wielded greater power than he did and the caste-prejudiced mindset of civil society.
Let us even concede that, in the course of this struggle, he conducted himself in ways unbecoming of a High Court judge and issued orders that were inappropriate for his office.
But in its essence, his resistance was directed towards the democratisation of judicial power.
It therefore possessed a democratic morality.
To overlook that morality and identify only irrational behaviour and absurd orders in his actions amounts to practising Brahminism even in the very understanding of resistance.
Above all, what explains the mindset that feels neither intolerance nor outrage when "civilised, Savarna" judges misuse their authority for personal gain, power, and ideologies of hatred, but reserves its intolerance and outrage for Dalit judge Karnan's struggle in defence of judicial values, even if some of his actions could at times be described as extreme?
Shivasundar is an activist and freelance journalist. Views expressed here are the author’s own.
Follow TNM's WhatsApp channel for news updates and story links.