Inclusion is an invitation to someone else’s table

What does it mean to be Dalit in queer spaces and queer in Dalit spaces? Reflecting on the limits of solidarity in social movements, Dr Sumit Baudh delivered a speech at the recent Social Justice Conclave organised by the National Campaign on Dalit Human Rights. This piece has excerpts, reproduced with their permission.
Protesters holding a sign that reads "Dalit Lives Matter" during a demonstration, with police in the foreground, highlighting caste-based discrimination issues in India.
A woman holding a placard saying 'Dalit lives matter'
Written by:
Published on: 

You ask what these contradictions say about solidarity. I will make two points, and then I will say what I think it takes to move beyond visibility and inclusion.

Every movement has a default

First. Every movement has a default. One group is taken to speak for all. In the anti-racist movement, it was often Black men. In the women’s movement here, it was often dominant-caste Savarna women. In our movement, the anti-caste movement, it is often Dalit men who are cisgender and heterosexual. I say “our” because I am part of this movement. This is not an attack. It is a question we must ask ourselves.

Anxiety bigger than pride

Twenty-two years ago, with the invitation and support of NCDHR, I went to the World Social Forum in Mumbai in 2004. Some of my queer friends were also holding a pride walk there. I am Dalit, and I am queer. But I knew no open queer person in a Dalit group, and no open Dalit person in a queer group at the time. At the walk, I took a small pride flag and held it in front of my face. The flag was the size of a handkerchief. It did not really cover me. My anxiety was bigger than the flag. I was afraid someone from NCDHR might see me at the pride walk, and that might rupture my relationship with them. No one ever said that to my face.

Relationships with unspoken conditions

Relationships within movements can come with unspoken conditions. In April this year, at a consultation on transgender rights in Delhi, transgender Dalit activist Grace Banu said that we are all grandchildren of Babasaheb. She was told she would be given a DNA test to prove it. She was verbally attacked and subjected to hostility inside a movement for equality. From this platform and voice that I am given today, I want to condemn what happened at that consultation; I want to honour Grace Banu and say that I stand with her. 

Identity is not enough 

Second. Identity is not enough. Lived experience is where understanding begins, and everyone on this panel brings it. I am also here partly because of the identities assigned to me. But the identities assigned to us on a stage do not tell us whether our institutions work any differently. Intersectionality is not a list of identities, and it is not addition. We say “double oppression,” as if caste and gender were two numbers to be added. They are not separate. Each shapes how the other is lived. Intersectionality is a way of seeing how power works, and who is left out when we plan, speak and decide.

The limits of solidarity 

So what do these contradictions say about solidarity? That standing together against a common enemy is not enough. It can hide hierarchy inside. In a famous speech to the Constituent Assembly in 1949, chairperson of the Drafting Committee Dr Ambedkar said that liberty, equality and fraternity must be held together. As a union of trinity, fraternity is the value we speak of the least. Fraternity means we are responsible to each other, above all to the person who is heard the least.

Visibility is a moment

How do we move beyond visibility and inclusion? Visibility is a moment. It comes and it goes, and the same people begin again. In 2015, three queer Dalit persons spoke together from a public stage at Delhi Pride. It was powerful. It did not become something that lasted. In the media, the same few faces are introduced again and again, as if for the first time. We know the faces. The conditions they speak about do not change.

An invitation to someone else’s table 

Inclusion is an invitation to someone else’s table. Transformation is when those who were guests help decide how the table is built. The law shows this too. In 2024, the Supreme Court accepted that Scheduled Castes are not all alike, and that help must reach those who are furthest behind. This year, in 2026, the Rajasthan High Court held that adding transgender persons to the list of backward classes was not enough, and that their distinct place must be recognised. In practice, a transgender person from a Scheduled Caste can lose the caste-based recognition they already had. A table set for one group at a time cannot seat people who belong to more than one.

Three tests 

Here are three tests for our movements and institutions. Who speaks first? Who decides? Who keeps the record? Count who is on our stages, our boards and our budgets. Write it down. Do it again next year. What is not counted is forgotten. And make the change before someone has to put their life at stake to demand that change.

One question I carry

I do not have all the answers. I have come to learn from this conclave. A panel such as this today would have been much harder to hold ten years ago. I carry one question. What changed in the last ten years that makes this panel possible? And what must we count and record, so that we do not have to win the same recognition again and again?

Thank you.

Sumit Baudh (they/he) is a Professor of Law at Jindal Global University and the author of Law at the Intersection of Caste, Class and Sex (forthcoming, Routledge). They write on caste, gender and sexuality in law, most recently on queer Dalit assertion in Social & Legal Studies. Dalit and queer, they write from inside both movements and from long experience of how each can overlook the other. 

Follow TNM's WhatsApp channel for news updates and story links.