

The testimonies at a public hearing on polygamy brought into sharp focus the devastating consequences of the practice. Women survivors spoke about betrayal and abandonment and how they had to raise their children on their own while their husbands wedded a second or third time.
The public hearing, organised in Mumbai on Thursday, November 19 by the Bharatiya Muslim Mahila Andolan (BMMA) or the Indian Muslim Women’s movement, brought together women survivors of polygamous marriages from different states including West Bengal, Karnataka, Gujarat, Maharashtra and Odisha. Women from Delhi and Tamil Nadu, unable to travel, shared their testimonies through video recordings.
For nearly two decades, BMMA has been at the forefront of the struggle to codify Muslim personal law – which remains largely uncodified – as Muslim women bear the consequences of its patriarchal interpretations. The absence of a comprehensive, codified Muslim family law has allowed unequal practices to persist, often leaving women without adequate remedies when their rights are violated, including prevalence of polygamy as legally valid.
I have personally never quite understood the argument made by many that one need not highlight triple talaq and polygamy given the political climate in the country and also because the ‘numbers do not match up’. As an Indian Muslim woman who has worked closely with survivors for over 15 years now, I have realised that the time will never be right for us women to speak for our own rights and we will be asked to sacrifice our causes for the ‘larger cause’ of the community. My question is why can’t both go hand in hand? I work on community rights, human rights and Muslim women’s rights. What is wrong in considering my own rights to be part of the community rights that I work on?
Almost all the survivors were unanimous in demanding that Section 82 (punishment for bigamy) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) should apply equally to the Muslim community. As one of the survivors asked, “Why should a woman’s protection against a husband’s second marriage depend upon the religion into which she was born?”
The hearing also brought together an eminent panel of experts and public figures, including Chief Qazi of Mumbai and advocate Mehtab Huseini, journalist Jyoti Punwani, social activist Shamsuddin Tamboli, peace activist Feroze Mithiborwala, eminent Islamic scholar Dr Zeenat Shaukat Ali and a representative of the Maharashtra State Commission for Women.
Dr Ali reiterated what BMMA and other Muslim feminist movements have been saying for very long – that contrary to popular belief, Islam actually restricts polygamy.
Selective interpretation of texts by patriarchal clergy has completely missed out on the Quranic foundations of justice. The Quran itself states in Surah An-Nisa (4:3), “If you fear that you will not be just, then marry only one.” It further acknowledges in Surah An-Nisa (4:129) that complete justice between wives is beyond human capacity. These verses provide a compelling theological foundation for monogamy.
Polygamy therefore being defended as an unconditional religious entitlement while ignoring the Quran’s insistence on justice is unacceptable to many of us. Muslim-majority countries such as Turkey and Tunisia have already shown the way, with Turkey prohibiting polygamy in 1926 and Tunisia in 1956.
BMMA has no political affiliations and its demand for a ban on polygamy is grounded in extensive research and ground level work. Its 2025 study, ‘Breaking the Silence: Lived Reality of 2500 Indian Muslim Women in Polygamous Marriages’, documents the experiences of 2,500 women and the impact that polygamy has had on their lives. The study found that 85% of respondents wanted polygamy to be legally invalid, demonstrating that opposition to the practice comes from the Muslim women living this reality themselves. The research also highlighted how nearly half the respondents reported no income and approximately two-thirds earned less than Rs 5,000 per month. These findings challenge the frequently repeated claim that polygamy is a necessary or desirable religious practice to help women.
The organisation has pursued this struggle through research, community mobilisation, legal interventions, among other efforts. Along with other petitioners, BMMA has approached the Supreme Court through public interest litigation seeking an end to polygamy. Yet the demand for a comprehensive Muslim family law remains unanswered.
BMMA co-founder Noorjahan Safia Niaz underlined the urgency of this demand. “If we don’t get a codified Muslim Family Law by 2037, it would be a 100 years that the Muslim community would be without legal protection within the family. It is time that the state fulfills its constitutional obligation towards Muslim women.”
BMMA has been demanding codification for nearly two decades now. It is essential to establish clear rights, responsibilities and remedies in matters of marriage, divorce, maintenance, custody, guardianship and inheritance.
Equally significant is the transformation taking place among Muslim women themselves. Having been a BMMA member for nearly 15 years now, I have seen this transformation very closely. BMMA’s two decades of activism are part of a wider movement in which Muslim women are increasingly challenging patriarchal authority, asserting their constitutional citizenship and claiming the right to speak for themselves – and the testimonies in the hearing were proof.
As BMMA co-founder Zakia Soman observed: “We are seeing a visible change in the last two decades in India about what can be called a new Muslim woman. She is conscious of her rights as a citizen of India as well as equality as a Muslim. The women-led movement against instant triple talaq and against CAA-NRC are two examples. Besides, Muslim women are shining across different fields professionally even as they are becoming more aware socially. While the state agencies continue to falter as was most recently evident in the treatment and release of rapists of Bilkis Banu, she herself is nothing short of a hero for every woman who believes in justice and self-respect. Gone are the days when conservative males spoke on her behalf and decided her fate, for she refuses to be treated as second class.”
This emerging assertion of agency is perhaps one of the most important developments in contemporary Muslim women’s politics. Muslim women are refusing to be represented solely through the voices of conservative religious leadership or reduced to symbols in political debates. Their participation in movements against instant triple talaq and CAA-NRC reflects a broader insistence on dignity, equality and democratic citizenship.
The struggle against polygamy must be understood within this larger context. It is neither a campaign against religion nor an attempt to undermine community identity. It is a demand that Muslim women should not be denied legal protections available to other citizens. A gender-just Muslim family law would strengthen the rights of women within the community while affirming the constitutional promise of equal citizenship.
Mariya Salim is the co-founder of women’s alliance Zariya. She is a human rights activist and an international sexual- and gender-based violence expert based in Delhi. She is a member of the BMMA.
Views expressed are the author’s own.