Karnataka Cabinet to confiscate book misrepresenting Lingayat faith

The Karnataka Cabinet has decided to confiscate copies of Ravi Hanj’s book Basava Mantapa and initiate legal action against its author and publisher following protests by Veerashaiva-Lingayat organisations alleging that it distorts Basavanna’s teachings and insults him.
Karnataka Deputy CM G Parameshwara has said that the Cabinet plans to confiscate the controversial book.
Karnataka Deputy CM G Parameshwara has said that the Cabinet plans to confiscate the controversial book.
Written by:
Published on: 

The Karnataka Cabinet on Thursday, November 19, decided to confiscate copies of Basava Mantapa, a new Kannada book by US-based writer Ravi Hanj, following protests by several Veerashaiva-Lingayat organisations. 

Announcing the decision after a prolonged discussion at the Cabinet meeting, Deputy Chief Minister G Parameshwara said the government had decided to seize copies of the book in circulation and initiate action under the provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS).

“Normally, we do not take swift action based on petitions. But in this case, a decision was taken since its impact is likely to be felt across the State,” he said.

Asked why the government had not constituted an expert committee to examine the book before taking action, Parameshwara said senior Ministers had discussed the issue at the Cabinet meeting. “This is only the initial reaction and we will look into the legality later. Action has been taken as per the provisions of BNS. We could not be silent spectators,” he said.

What is in the book?

The controversy centres on Hanj's arguments about the origins and philosophy of the Lingayat faith in Basava Mantapa. In a recent interview with Vishwavani TV, he said the book was based on documented evidence and examined the Veerashaiva-Lingayat community before, during and after Basavanna.

Hanj argued that Veerashaivas and Lingayats belonged to the same Shaiva tradition, which, according to him, evolved through different phases and came to be known as Kalamukha, Veerashaiva and later Lingayat. He claimed that the discovery of tiny lingas during excavations at Harappa and Mohenjo-daro, he said the history of the tradition could be traced to ancient times.

He also contended that Basavanna did not establish the Lingayat faith and did not oppose Sanatana traditions in the manner described by some Lingayat leaders.

Controversy over new book

The decision came amid mounting pressure from Lingayat community organisations and political leaders cutting across party lines who have alleged that the book distorts the teachings and philosophy of Basavanna and insults the 12th-century social reformer. 

Addressing a press conference in Bengaluru on Thursday, Basava Samiti president Aravind Jatti alleged that the book hurt the sentiments of the Lingayat community and Basavanna's followers under the guise of research. He demanded that criminal cases be registered against those responsible for disturbing public peace.

Jatti objected to the book's portrayal of Basavanna, who propagated the ideals of equality, a casteless society, dignity of labour and the concept of a parliament. He rejected Hanj's reported apology and offer to make corrections, insisting that the community would accept neither.

“They have mistaken the peaceful nature of the Veerashaiva-Lingayat community for weakness. It is condemnable that the book has been presented as a work of research to disguise its objectionable content,” he said.

“What is happening now is an ideological conspiracy aimed at undermining the Sharana philosophy and Lingayat identity. We know who is behind it,” he added.

Jatti also alleged that such developments had intensified since the State government declared Basavanna the cultural leader of Karnataka. 

BJP State president BY Vijayendra had also sought action against the author and publisher in a social media post.

Large and Medium Industries Minister MB Patil criticised Veerashaiva Mahasabha president Shankar Bidari and former Kannada Sahitya Parishat president Manu Baligar for attending the book's release event. He said it was for the Veerashaiva Mahasabha to decide what action should be taken against Bidari.

Aland MLA BR Patil alleged that Hanj had written the book with malicious intent to tarnish Basavanna's reputation. Former Mayor of the London Borough of Lambeth Neeraj Patil and thinker JS Patil also called for stringent action against the author and publisher.

Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Minister Eshwar Khandre, who is also president of the All-India Veerashaiva Mahasabha, welcomed the Cabinet's decision. In a statement, he said the Cabinet had also agreed to write to the Centre seeking the removal of Hanj's videos from social media.

Protests

MB Patil warned that the community would no longer tolerate what he described as attacks on Basavanna and the Lingayat tradition. He said protests had already begun in several parts of Karnataka and neighbouring Maharashtra.

“We will take to the street and launch an intense agitation,” he said.

The Jagatika Lingayat Mahasabha organised a demonstration in Belagavi on Friday, November 20. Members of the organisation and other Veerashaiva-Lingayat groups will submit a memorandum to Chief Minister DK Shivakumar through the Deputy Commissioner's office, demanding legal action against the author, publisher and the editor of Vishwavani TV.

Mahasabha convenor Basavaraja Rotti said similar protests would be held in several districts. The organisation has also lodged a complaint with the Market police in Belagavi against Hanj, an unnamed publisher and the channel's editor.

Legal action

The Cabinet has also cleared legal action against the author and the book’s publisher, journalist Vishweshwar Bhat.

The Basava Samiti submitted a complaint to the High Grounds police in Bengaluru seeking an FIR against the author and publisher. The police said they had received the complaint but were yet to register an FIR.

Not the first time 

The controversy over Basava Mantapa comes against the backdrop of earlier tensions over competing interpretations of Basavanna’s teachings and the identity of the Veerashaiva-Lingayat community. 

In a rare show of unity, the Akhila Bharata Veerashaiva Mahasabha and Jagathika Lingayat Mahasabha had come together in February 2025 to oppose Vachana Darshana, a book published by Ayodhya Publications, alleging that the book misrepresented Basavanna and the vachanas. 

The two organisations, which had differed over the demand for a separate religious status for Lingayats in 2017-18, released a 308-page counter-publication, Vachana Darshana-Satya versus Mithya, accusing the earlier book of promoting an agenda to divide the community. 

Follow TNM's WhatsApp channel for news updates and story links.