Author Ravi Hanj arrested over book for ‘distorting’ Basavanna’s teachings

The author’s arrest comes amid protests over his book ‘Basava Mantapa’, which has been accused of distorting the teachings of 12th-century social reformer Basavanna. The Karnataka government has ordered confiscation of copies of the book and approved legal action against the author and publisher.
Author Ravi Hanj arrested over book for ‘distorting’ Basavanna’s teachings
Written by:
Published on: 

Chicago-based Kannada author Ravi Hanj was arrested by the Karnataka Police on Saturday, November 21 after he was detained at the Kochi International Airport while attempting to leave the country. The arrest comes amid mounting protests over his book Basava Mantapa, which has been accused of distorting the teachings and philosophy of 12th-century social reformer Basavanna.

The controversy has triggered protests across Karnataka and drawn criticism from political leaders cutting across party lines. The state government has decided to confiscate copies of the book and initiate legal action against Hanj and its publisher, Kannada journalist and Vishwavani editor Vishweshwar Bhat.

Hanj was detained after airport security alerted Karnataka Police over a Look Out Circular (LOC) issued against him. He was subsequently brought to Bengaluru and arrested. He faces multiple complaints, including one in Belagavi.

The 600-page book has sparked outrage over its arguments on the origins of the Lingayat faith, the relationship between Veerashaivas and Lingayats, and Basavanna’s teachings.

Among the statements attributed to Hanj are that Veerashaivas and Lingayats belong to the same tradition, that Basavanna’s followers were originally called ‘Lingahathas’ and not ‘Lingayats’, and that Basavanna used money from King Bijjala’s treasury for charity. Hanj has also described the Sharana literature, which contains Basavanna’s teachings, as contradictory.

Critics allege that these arguments misrepresent Basavanna’s philosophy and undermine the ideals of the Lingayat movement.

Chief Minister DK Shivakumar condemned the book in a social media post on Friday. “The government will not remain silent if the honour of our Basavanna is violated. However, it is condemnable that an author named Ravi Hanj has written a controversial book titled ‘Basava Mantapa’ and insulted Basavanna in a very derogatory manner. Our government will not tolerate this insult to a great social reformer who was a beacon for the entire human race,” he said.

Shivakumar also warned that the government would take legal action against those who wrote about revered personalities in a manner that could disturb public order.

Dispute centres on Hanj’s interpretation

Basavanna was a 12th-century social reformer whose teachings challenged caste discrimination and untouchability. He advocated equality, dignity of labour, selfless sharing and a casteless society. His philosophy was expressed through Vachanas, short lyrical compositions written in Kannada.

The controversy centres on Hanj’s interpretation of Basavanna’s place in the history of the Lingayat faith.

In an interview with Vishwavani TV, Hanj said Basava Mantapa was based on documented evidence and examined the Veerashaiva-Lingayat tradition before, during and after Basavanna.

He argued that Veerashaivas and Lingayats belonged to the same Shaiva tradition, which evolved through different phases and came to be known as Kalamukha, Veerashaiva and later Lingayat. He also claimed that the tradition could be traced to ancient times, citing the discovery of small lingas during excavations at Harappa and Mohenjo-daro.

Hanj further argued that Basavanna did not establish the Lingayat faith and did not oppose Sanatana traditions in the manner described by some Lingayat leaders.

In the interview, he questioned Basavanna’s actions in relation to King Bijjala’s treasury, arguing that they appeared inconsistent with the Vachana ‘Kalabeda, Kolabeda’ (Do not steal, do not kill).

Hanj later apologised for his remarks, saying his views had been misinterpreted.

Political and community backlash

The book has drawn opposition from Lingayat organisations and political leaders, including those who have historically differed over the community’s religious identity.

Basava Samiti president Aravind Jatti, addressing a press conference in Bengaluru, alleged that the book hurt the sentiments of the community under the guise of research. He demanded criminal action against those responsible.

Jatti objected to the portrayal of Basavanna, saying it undermined his teachings on equality, a casteless society, dignity of labour and the concept of a parliament. He also rejected Hanj’s apology and offer to make corrections.

“What is happening now is an ideological conspiracy aimed at undermining the Sharana philosophy and Lingayat identity. We know who is behind it,” he said.

Former Karnataka Chief Minister BS Yediyurappa also condemned the book, saying that any remarks disparaging Basavanna were unacceptable.

BJP state president BY Vijayendra has also sought action against the author and publisher.

Industries Minister MB Patil, a Lingayat leader, criticised the book and questioned the author about being in the United States while protests were taking place in Karnataka. “Basava-hater Ravi Hanj’s deceit exposed; handed over to the police!” Patil said after the author’s arrest.

Patil also criticised Veerashaiva Mahasabha president Shankar Bidari and former Kannada Sahitya Parishat president Manu Baligar for attending the book’s release event.

Aland MLA BR Patil alleged that Hanj had written the book with malicious intent to tarnish Basavanna’s reputation. Former Mayor of the London Borough of Lambeth, Neeraj Patil, and thinker JS Patil also called for stringent action.

Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Minister Eshwar Khandre, who is also president of the All-India Veerashaiva Mahasabha, welcomed the Cabinet’s decision. He said the government would also write to the Union seeking removal of Hanj’s videos from social media.

A long-running debate over Lingayat identity

The controversy has revived a longstanding debate over whether Lingayats and Veerashaivas are distinct communities and whether Lingayats should be recognised under a separate religion.

A section of Lingayat leaders has for decades sought to formally delink the community from Hinduism. They distinguish Lingayats from Veerashaivas, arguing that the latter are either a sub-sect or a Hinduised version of the community. Others maintain that the two belong to the same religious tradition.

The debate intensified ahead of the 2018 Karnataka Assembly elections, when the then Congress government led by Siddaramaiah recommended minority religion status for Lingayats, distinguishing them from Veerashaivas. The BJP, led by Yediyurappa, opposed the move and accused the Congress of attempting to divide Hindu voters.

The latest controversy is also not the first time Basavanna’s legacy has become the subject of an ideological dispute.

In November 2024, the publication of Vachana Darshana by RSS-affiliated organisations Ayodhya Publications and Prajna Pravah triggered criticism from several scholars and Lingayat groups. The book argued that Basavanna’s teachings had been misinterpreted by Left-leaning thinkers and academics.

Critics objected to its portrayal of the Vachanas as an extension of Vedic teachings, arguing that this contradicted Basavanna’s emphasis on challenging caste hierarchies and religious orthodoxy.

In February 2025, the Akhila Bharata Veerashaiva Mahasabha and Jagathika Lingayat Mahasabha, organisations that had differed over the demand for separate religion status, came together to oppose the publication.

They released a 308-page counter-publication titled Vachana Darshana-Satya versus Mithya, accusing the earlier book of distorting Basavanna’s teachings and attempting to divide the community.

Protests and legal action

Protests have been reported in several parts of Karnataka and neighbouring Maharashtra. Protesters have publicly torn and burnt copies of the book.

The Jagatika Lingayat Mahasabha organised a demonstration in Belagavi on November 20. Members of the organisation submitted a memorandum to the Chief Minister through the Deputy Commissioner’s office, demanding action against Hanj, the publisher, and the editor of Vishwavani TV.

The organisation has also filed a complaint with the Market police in Belagavi.

Separately, the Basava Samiti submitted a complaint to the High Grounds police in Bengaluru, seeking an FIR against Hanj and Bhat. The police said they had received the complaint but were yet to register an FIR.

The state Cabinet has approved confiscation of copies of the book and legal action against the author and publisher.

Follow TNM's WhatsApp channel for news updates and story links.