25.84% of this wealth was made over six days in August – just a fortnight after he helped the fall of the Congress-JD(S) coalition government

news Politics Friday, November 15, 2019 - 18:44

Karnataka’s richest politician MTB Nagaraj got richer by Rs 185.7 crore in a span of just 18 months, his latest affidavit shows. MTB Nagaraj was one of the 17 rebel MLAs from Congress and JD(S), whose defection in July led to the fall of the coalition government headed by HD Kumaraswamy, making way for the BJP to clinch power in the state. Curiously, his affidavit for the upcoming bye-election in Hoskote, where he is contesting on a BJP ticket, shows 53 term deposits mainly between August 2 and 7, amounting to over Rs 48 crore.

This amount is over 25.84% of the total increase in Nagaraj’s wealth in this 18-month period. 

According to the latest affidavit, Nagaraj and his wife Shanthakumari are worth Rs 1201.50 crore. This is a 15.5% increase in his wealth compared to the assets he declared in May 2018, ahead of the Karnataka Assembly election. A comparison of Nagaraj’s affidavits filed in 2018 and 2019 show that his movable assets increased by Rs 104.53 crore. His wife, Shanthakumari’s movable assets increased by Rs 44.95 crore.

On July 27, and between August 2 and 7, there were 53 term deposits made in Canara Bank, most of them upward Rs 90 lakh each. While there are also other term deposits in his account, those are reflected in his earlier affidavits too. 

So how did MTB Nagaraj accumulate so much money in such a short span of time, his detractors ask.

MTB Nagaraj
Assets
2019 (Rs)2018 (Rs)Difference (Rs)Shanthakumari
Assets
2019 (Rs)2018 (Rs)Difference (Rs)
Cash in hand43,44,9276,67,53236,77,395Cash in hand4,50,0004,89,999-39,999
Savings account4,53,32,1095,39,58,205-86,26,096Savings account27,04,50262,19,616-35,15,114
Term Deposit1,34,56,45,9661,21,85,13,17212,71,32,794Term Deposit32,40,00,00020,13,97,42012,26,02,580
Capital Investment5,85,42,39448,00,84,661-42,15,42,267Capital Investment94,69,15,24193,55,39,0551,13,76,186
Capital investment2,84,60,6052,87,75,817-3,15,212Capital Investment4,49,08,5584,49,08,558Nil
Personal loans given2,71,80,65,7342,33,79,47,74138,01,17,993Personal loans given31,27,38,48626,00,00031,01,38,486
Motor vehicles2,54,13,9642,14,46,88739,67,077Motor vehicles1,72,82,4341,72,82,434Nil
Jewellery2,23,32,8132,23,32,813NilJewellery1,72,82,4341,72,82,434Nil
Any other assets6,46,4296,46,429NilAny other assetsNilNilNil
Total movable assets4,24,97,84,9413,14,75,54,7851,04,53,08,946Total movable assets1,67,34,57,4061,22,40,09,25844,94,48,148
Agricultural land31,09,73,30230,86,75,50422,97,798Agricultural land26,40,00,00024,00,00,00024,000,000
Non-agricultural land3,09,86,16,1032,81,26,45,72828,59,70,375Non-agricultural land94,47,07,50085,88,25,0008,58,82,500
Commercial buildings39,65,30,43139,65,30,431NilCommercial buildings28,10,00,00028,10,00,000Nil
Residential buildings39,14,89,14642,85,01,646-3,70,12,500Residential buildings40,44,87,00046,02,87,000-5,58,00,000
Total immovable assets4,19,76,08,9823,94,63,53,30925,12,55,673Total immovable assets1,89,41,94,5001,84,01,12,0005,40,82,500
Total assets8,44,73,93,9237,09,39,08,0941,29,65,64,619Total assets3,56,76,51,9063,06,41,21,25850,35,30,648

*In MTB Nagaraj's affidavit copy, the gross total value of movable assets was mentioned as Rs 4,19,28,63,731. However, when TNM calculated the total value, we got the figure of Rs 4,24,97,84,941

Both Congress and JD(S) have alleged multiple times that all MLAs, who defected, were paid close to Rs 50 crore. Nagaraj and another former Congress MLA, Dr K Sudhakar, had resigned from their posts as MLAs on July 10. Between July 10 and 15, Nagaraj had held talks with senior Congress leaders and had said that he would withdraw his resignation, if Sudhakar did too.

Just when Congress leaders were expecting Nagaraj to stick by the party, on July 15, he announced that there was no question of him taking back his resignation. He also boarded a private charter plane along with Chief Minister BS Yediyurappa’s assistant Santhosh after making the statement.

MTB Nagaraj boarding the private charter plane to Mumbai on July 15

The coalition government fell after Kumaraswamy lost the vote of confidence on July 23. BS Yediyurappa took oath as the Chief Minister on July 26. Three days later, the rebels returned to Bengaluru from their luxury-hotel stay in Mumbai. 

Four days later, the first string of transactions amounting to Rs 13.91 crore were made in the form of 15 term deposits in MTB Nagaraj’s name. A couple of days later, Rs 18.61 crore was deposited as 21 different term deposits. On August 5, Rs 14.86 crore was deposited as 16 term deposits, and finally on August 7, Rs 92.91 lakh was deposited as a term deposit. Each deposit that was made into these bank accounts was over Rs 90 lakh, but short of Rs 1 crore.

DateAmountNumber of
bank accounts
Total
02.08.1992,77,31654,63,86,583
02.08.19927647154,63,82,355
02.08.1992,74,78054,63,73,900
04.08.19927561376,49,29,291
04.08.199,34,27,98109,34,27,980
04.08.1992,64,84421,85,29,688
04.08.1983,47,292183,47,292
04.08.199,27,47719,27,477
05.08.1992,87,4571614,85,99,312
07.08.1992,91,264192,91,264
Grand total  48,31,95,142