South Central

Journalism in the age of influencers | South Central @ 100

Who gets to be called a journalist today? South Central examines who gets to be called a journalist in the age of influencers, the blurred lines between journalism, activism and opinion, and the questions of credibility, accountability and political influence in an evolving media landscape.

Dhanya Rajendran, Pooja Prasanna

A smartphone can record a protest, document police action and bring stories from the ground to thousands of people. But does that make the person behind the camera a journalist? And when an influencer describes themselves as an independent journalist, what should audiences expect from them?

Listen and follow on YouTube

Listen and follow on Apple

Listen and follow on Spotify

These questions form the basis of the 100th episode of South Central, as former host, Leena Reghunath returns to South Central for the special 100th episode along with hosts Dhanya Rajendran and Pooja Prasanna. They are joined by Carl Lafrenais, Meghnad and Priyanshi Sharma of Peek TV for a conversation on journalism, credibility and the growing role of content creators in news.

The conversation begins with Meghnad arguing that neither the government nor the Supreme Court should decide who qualifies as a journalist. For him, the people doing the work should be recognised as such. He points to those who are on the ground, recording events and preserving evidence.

He also questions the expectation that journalists can be completely unbiased. Even when someone reporting from the ground brings in their own opinions, Meghnad argues, that does not necessarily mean they stop being a journalist. The discussion also touches on the right of people to record police action during protests. Meghnad asks why the police can record citizens, while citizens are not afforded the same protection when recording the police. “The state is allowed to do that to me, but I am not allowed to do that to them?” he asks.

Priyanshi however, says there should be distinctions between journalists, influencers and activists, as blurred roles can affect how audiences trust a story. “When those lines between an influencer, a journalist and an activist get blurred, then the story suffers a little bit,” she says.

The conversation also examines how journalism has changed with the shift from print to television and digital media. Leena says the industry is still grappling with what defines a journalist, arguing that the focus should be on delivering “facts, fact-based information objectively with some sense of editorial supervision”.

Carl argues that influencers can also do journalism if their work is backed by facts and research. “A ring light doesn't make you a journalist, but neither does a studio costing 20 crore rupees,” he says.

The conversation also turns to concerns about the use of the label ‘independent journalist’, particularly when political propaganda, campaigns and paid collaborations are presented as independent reporting.

Towards the end, the conversation turns to how independent creators can support one another. Meghnad speaks about young people going to the ground and reporting without financial backing, questioning why they should be dismissed for not belonging to established organisations. Carl points to examples from Brazil and Serbia, where content creators came together to promote each other's work.

Tune into the full discussion here.

Audio timecodes:

00:00:00 - Introduction

00:03:53 - Headlines

00:08:14 - Journalism in the age of influencers

01:13:27 - AMA

01:31:08 - Recommendations

References

Why Andhra local body nominations turned violent | LME 174 | Pooja Prasanna

How BJP helped ‘Judicial Krishnamoorthy’ get five elephants to Tamil Nadu

The costs of Reliance’s wildlife ambitions

Recommendations

Dhanya Rajendran

BANANAGRAMS

Pooja Prasanna

The enduring personality cult of Narendra Modi

Leena Reghunath

Mary Slusser’s secret loot of Nepal’s sacred art and heritage

The rise and rise of the Pakistan military’s PR machine

Meghnad

Citizen Sane: A Wild Guide to Civics

30 Rock

The costs of Reliance’s wildlife ambitions

Carl Lafrenais

The Office

The Crowd: A Study of the Popular Mind

Priyanshi Sharma

Koffee with Karan

Knives Out Trilogy

Check out the recommendations and references from this episode.

Check out the list of headlines discussed in South Central

Support South Central: https://pages.razorpay.com/south-central

Send your thoughts, suggestions, and criticism as well.

Contribute to our reporting fund. Click here

To check out our other shows, Click here 

To not miss any updates, join TNM's WhatsApp Channel! Click here

You can also let us know what you think by filling out our quick feedback form. Your suggestions help shape future episodes of South Central. 

To not miss any updates, join TNM's WhatsApp Channel! Click here

Producer - Akshay Lal, Editor -Jaseem Ali, Camera - Ajay R, Social Media - Anakha CJ

Follow TNM's WhatsApp channel for news updates and story links.