How Dengue Has Breached India’s Class Barriers

By Aarti Kelkar-Khambete, Indiaspend.org

As the current dengue epidemic in Delhi and other urban areas of India such as Mumbai, Pune and Bangalore indicates, a once-obscure disease of poor neighbourhoods has become a great leveller, affecting and scaring both rich and poor and laying bare the infirmities of public healthcare.

The Comptroller & Auditor General (CAG), the central government’s auditor, has ordered an audit of Delhi’s handling of the epidemic as it prepares to analyse the preparedness in other states hit by dengue.Health experts contend that very little has been learnt despite annual dengue epidemics striking with almost clockwork precision.

The world’s fastest-spreading tropical disease struck Bollywood actress Kareena Kapoor Khanearlier this year, one of the high-profile patients of the mosquito-borne virus that resides in the Aedes aegypti mosquito.

The mosquito has invaded Mumbai’s toniest areas, Malabar Hills and Juhu. Many public figures, such as actors Juhi Chawla, Anil Kapoor and Jeetendra, were issued notices after mosquito breeding sites were found in their homes and gardens.

Dengue is not new to India, but there has been a sharp rise in dengue cases over the past two decades, with a 50% increase over 2014, the rich being hit as hard as the poor and rural areas increasingly being affected.

Striking rich and poor, dengue ravages India more than any other country

“Now you can find dengue-causing mosquitoes even in posh buildings, but people there do not allow (municipal corporation) workers to come and spray inside,” said Shantabai (she uses only one name), a domestic worker in Pune.

Poor research, late prevention, flawed implementation, a shortage of specialists and limited community involvement hinders India’s dengue-control programme.

Recognising the gravity of the situation, the World Health Organisation included dengue in its list of important vector-borne diseases that need to be controlled on a priority basis in 2014. (1)

Of an estimated 96 million cases globally every year, 70% occur in Asia, with India alone contributing about a third, 34%, of all cases. (1)

India had 33 million apparent dengue cases and 100 million asymptomatic infections every year, more than any other country, reported a recent Oxford University study. (2)

Source: Central Bureau of Health Intelligence (2009, 2012,2015) National Health Profile. Government of India

A comparison of year-wise data related to dengue and malaria in India shows that malarial deaths have been decreasing while the number of deaths due to dengue has gone the other way with a small dip in deaths in 2013. (8)

Source: Central Bureau of Health Intelligence (2009, 2012,2015) National Health Profile. Government of India

State-wise dengue reporting shows that cases have doubled this year over last.

The most affected states (with dengue cases above 1,500), according to National Vector Borne Disease Control Programme (NVBDCP), include Delhi (the highest number of dengue cases recorded), followed by Karnataka,  Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat, Maharashtra, Punjab and Arunachal Pradesh.

Although studies have shown a high occurrence of dengue in the Indian subcontinent, only a fraction of clinically apparent cases is diagnosed and reported; the true burden of the disease remains uncertain. (3)

Very few studies have attempted to measure the extent of transmission through the population. (4)

What’s changed over the past two decades

Both urban and rural areas exposed: Dengue has spread from urban areas to rural.(5) The disease has recently spread to hilly regions, such as the Nilgiris and Cardamom Hills, and larger and more frequent outbreaks have been reported

Higher and middle-income groups in urban areas affected: Recent examples from cities such as Pune show that the infection trend has changed and is now expanding into higher- and middle-income groups. (6)

Not just hot and humid climates impacted: Once limited to tropical areas, dengue outbreaks have also been reported from areas with sub-tropical and desert conditions, astwo recent studies reported. (1)

Rapid unplanned development and urbanisation are triggers: Although unseasonal rains have been found to trigger the epidemic, other reasons include rapid, unplanned development and urbanisation, increase in construction sites, where the Aedesmosquito breeds, inefficient garbage management and the use of plastic bags and containers. Some call it a “runaway epidemic“. (1)

Ignorance worsens the situation: Storage of water because of irregular supply has also found to help the Aedes mosquito breed. (7) In cities, residents of high-rise buildings and posh apartments prevent health workers from visiting their flats for preventive fogging, triggering an increase in mosquitoes. (6)

New strains of the dengue virus: The situation has worsened this year. Although fourdengue serotypes were found to be circulating together in Delhi, scientists suspect a new strain may have emerged. This year has seen a predominance of the more dangerous type 2 and type 4 serotypes.

A tottering healthcare system: As the worst-hit city this year, Delhi’s health serviceshave been strained.

The virus has been difficult to control: In addition to the rapid spread of mosquitoes, the virus is believed to have mutated, becoming more resistant to medical treatment. Genetic changes in the virus have possibly helped it become hardier and more infectious. These factors have presented new challenges in the control of the virus and the vector, the Aedes aegypti (1)

Are vaccines the answer?

Science is finding that vaccines are not practical due to the complicated nature of theepidemic. (1)

Blocking the channel of transmission by improved prevention measures against the Aedesmosquito and better community awareness measures is a more sensible option. (1)

India could learn from other countries, such as Singapore, Thailand and Indonesia that have successfully kept dengue at bay.

—————-

References

1. Editorial (2015) Dengue: A runaway epidemic and a bewildered public health worker. Medical Journal Armed Forces India, 71, (2015), 3-4

2. Gupta and Ballani (2014) Current perspectives on the spread of dengue in India. Infection and Drug Resistance 2014:7, 337–34

3. Shephard et al (2014) Economic and disease burden of dengue illness in India. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 91 (6), 2014, pp 1235-1242.

4. Rodriguez-Barraquer et al (2014) The hidden burden of dengue and chikungunya in Chennai, India. PLOS Neglected Tropical Diseases, 9 (7)

5. Khan, Dutta, Topno, Soni and Mahanta (2014) Dengue Outbreak in a Hilly State of Arunachal Pradesh in Northeast India. The Scientific World Journal, Volume 2014

6. Isalkar (2015) More dengue cases in upmarket areas, healthier picture in slums. The Times of India, Pune, August 17, 2015

7. The Times of India (2015) Dengue spurt blame on water in urban containers. The Times of India, Pune, Friday, October 2, 2015

8. Central Bureau of Health Intelligence (2009, 2012, 2015) National Health Profile. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India

(A version of this article previously appeared on the India Water Portal. Khambete, a consultant with India Water Portal, explores the relationships between health, water and the environment.)

Indiaspend.org is a data-driven, public-interest journalism non-profit